Choosing the Right Performance Marketing Agency: A In-depth Guide

Written By 1 Up Marketing

As businesses increasingly embrace data-driven marketing, the demand for performance marketing agencies has grown significantly. Unlike traditional marketing approaches that focus on reach and impressions, performance marketing is centered around tangible outcomes whether it’s leads, sales, downloads, or sign-ups.

Selecting the right performance marketing agency can make or break your growth strategy. This guide outlines the key considerations, questions to ask, and red flags to watch for when choosing a performance marketing partner.

What Makes a Performance Marketing Agency Different?

A performance marketing agency focuses on delivering measurable results. They work on a pay for performance model or are laser focused on KPIs such as cost per acquisition (CPA), return on ad spend (ROAS) and customer lifetime value (CLV).

The best agencies don’t just run ads, they manage end to end campaign execution, including:

  • Audience targeting

  • Creative development

  • Landing page optimisation

  • A/B testing

  • Conversion tracking and analytics

Step 1: Define Your Goals

Before you begin your search, clarify what success looks like for your business. Are you trying to:

  • Generate qualified leads?

  • Increase online sales?

  • Lower customer acquisition costs?

  • Enter new markets in New Zealand, Australia, or the USA?

Clear objectives help you evaluate which agency is best equipped to meet your needs.

Step 2: Evaluate Their Track Record

A reputable performance marketing agency should be able to demonstrate proven success across industries. Look for:

  • Case studies or client testimonials

  • Sample campaign metrics (e.g., ROAS, conversion rates)

  • Relevant experience in your sector (e.g., SaaS, real estate, professional services)

Don’t be afraid to ask for references or to speak directly with existing clients.

Step 3: Assess Their Strategic Capabilities

It’s not just about executing campaigns, it’s about crafting the right strategy. The ideal agency will:

  • Perform an in-depth audit of your current marketing efforts

  • Provide a clear roadmap aligned with your business goals

  • Tailor strategies to local markets (e.g., Auckland vs Sydney vs Los Angeles)

Ask how they approach audience segmentation, creative testing and budget allocation.

Step 4: Examine Their Tools and Tech Stack

Performance marketing thrives on data. Ensure the agency uses robust tools for:

  • Analytics and attribution (e.g. Google Analytics, HubSpot, Segment)

  • Ad management (e.g. Meta Ads Manager, Google Ads)

  • Automation and reporting

Transparency is key, ensure you’ll have access to performance dashboards and campaign data.

Step 5: Understand Their Communication Style

An agency can have all the technical skills in the world but if communication is poor, results will suffer. Gauge how proactive, clear and collaborative they are. Look for:

  • Regular check ins or strategy calls

  • Clear reporting timelines

  • Willingness to educate and align with your internal teams

Step 6: Compare Pricing Models

Agencies may offer different pricing structures, including:

  • Flat monthly retainers

  • Percentage of ad spend

  • Pay for performance models

  • Contract lengths

Choose a model that aligns with your business goals and is willing to build a long term relationship.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

  • Overpromising: Guarantees of “#1 ranking in Google” or “10x ROAS in 30 days” are unrealistic.

  • Lack of clarity: If they can’t explain their strategy in plain terms, they may not understand it themselves.

  • Opaque reporting: You should always know where your money is going and what it’s achieving.

  • Long term contracts for specific tactics: Your business will changes over time. A long term contract for a specific tactic (like Google Ad’s) may offer you no flexibility.

Why Local Expertise Matters

If your business operates across New Zealand, Australia, and the USA, find an agency with experience in those markets. Regional nuances such as consumer behaviour, media costs, and local regulations can have a major impact on campaign performance.

Localised campaigns that consider time zones, holidays, and cultural preferences often outperform generic global strategies.

Final Thoughts

The right performance marketing agency acts as an extension of your team. They are not just service providers they’re strategic partners invested in your success.

Take the time to vet your options thoroughly, define your goals clearly, and don’t settle for anything less than accountability, transparency and results.

At 1 Up, we specialise in connecting marketing to revenue through tailored, high-performance strategies.

If you’re ready to accelerate your growth, we’re here to help.

1 Up Marketing
Previous

Performance Marketing vs Traditional Marketing: What’s More Effective?